The objective of the workshop is to identify the advantages and disadvantages of studying Native Americans as a stand-alone group, or within the broader comparative frame of the study of indigeneity. This is a vexing question that involves weighing theoretical and historical considerations against the pragmatics of limited university resources, and an urgent concern with the recognition and study of Native American social conditions, culture, and thought. Our workshop opens a space for sustained consideration of this matter. The category “Native American” is one specific result and instance of the dialectics of identity formation around colonization, internal colonialism, and de-colonization. It refers to a set of peoples who suffered and who reconfigured their cultures and social institutions within the broad historical arc of British, French, and Spanish colonial expansion into North America, and subsequently within the national history of the United States. From the angle of a contemporary politics of recognition, the category also names a political space of identification.

Would the conceptual and comparative benefits of building a program around the more general category of indigeneity—a category that has been deployed across colonial worlds—outweigh sacrificing exclusive attention to the experience of Native Americans in the United States? Is there a way in which Native American Studies can be given pride of place within a program that acknowledges that indigeneity is a highly plastic idea, that has been used, for instance, to distinguish Black Dominicans from Haitians, to name “minorities” in the Soviet Union, and that has at times been substituted with a language of class (for instance, campesino, in the Bolivia of the 1950s)?

Our workshop seeks to explore the contours of comparative indigeneity studies and the place of Native American Studies within it. Its aim is to help us build a robust and intellectually coherent program in which Native American Studies can thrive.

Claudio Lomnitz
Director of the Center for the Study of Race and Ethnicity
William B. Ransford Professor of Anthropology

 

If you you would like to attend the symposium, please e-mail Andrea Thomas at at2222.